Tuesday, 2 June 2015

Parizeau; caricature, architect, and old fashioned separatist

Monsieur, has died.  Jacques Parizeau was an architect of the modern Quebec state, a key figure in the formation of the Parti Quebecois and the government of Rene Levesque.  Parizeau was Prime Minister of Quebec himself from 1994 to 1995 and came within one point of leading the province out of Canada in the 1995 referendum.  Parizeau, with his aristocratic demeanour, earned the nickname “Monsieur” as a result.  He was one of those francophone nationalists who often appeared to be more English in his personality than most anglophones.  One could almost imagine Parizeau secretly having tea with scones and marmalade or Devon cream or being a fan of cricket while trying not to openly look down with derision upon ordinary Quebecers who enjoy poutine, Pepsi, and beer.  Parizeau’s lord of the manor style was likely something he adopted in Britain when studying at the London School of Economics.  He also came from a wealthy Montreal family that had made a fortune in finance, an ironic achievement considering so many nationalists once criticized the English establishment for denying francophones the opportunity for wealth and social prestige.

Jacques Parizeau, even before revealing himself as a separatist, made an immense contribution to the modern economy of Quebec.  As an economic advisor to the Liberal government of Jean Lesage, he was closely involved with the expansion of Hydro-Quebec in the 1960’s which saw the government owned utility take over almost all of the remaining private electrical utilities in the province.  He created the Caisse de depot et placement, the massive government pension fund, the Regie des rentes (the Quebec equivalent to the Canada Pension Plan), and numerous other state enterprises that saw partial nationalization of various industries, including steel and asbestos.  Parizeau believed in the strength of government in the economy, and in most cases, he was very successful with his efforts.  Premier Wynne in Ontario should pay special attention to Quebec and understand the advantages of publicly-owned electrical utilities.  Stephen Harper should see the advantages of compulsory increases in government pension contributions and how they can significantly multiply when properly invested.

Of course, it was Jacques Parizeau who was Prime Minister of Quebec when the province narrowly voted to remain part of Canada on October 30, 1995.   The campaign opposing separation had been weak until the final days of the campaign, and the combination of Parizeau’s intellect and aggression with Bloc Quebecois Leader Lucien Bouchard’s charismatic personality almost led to a separatist win.  It was only during the final weeks with a major push from Canadian Prime Minister Jean Chretien and a mass rally in Montreal of 150,000 people supporting a united Canada did the scales narrowly tip in favour of federalism.  In conceding defeat on the evening of October 30, an allegedly drunk Parizeau blamed “money and ethnic votes” for the loss.  The racist remark ruined Parizeau’s career and he resigned from politics the next day.  Lucien Bouchard became the new leader of the PQ and Prime Minister of Quebec.


The death of Monsieur in a way represents a death of the separatist movement in the form it has usually been practiced.  Jacques Parizeau and Rene Levesque were social democrats.  Pierre-Karl Peladeau is a right-wing capitalist.  His presence will attempt to create an independent Quebec where big business can rule, unlike the state capitalism of his predecessors which attempted to create an economically egalitarian Quebec where as many individuals as possible could benefit from the collective wealth. 

No comments:

Post a Comment